Grimrock

X-Mas mod of the month

One Room ? (or is it non-competing ?)

Lol, I was debating that. Seems a bit pointless to put a mod to the vote that will have at least 20 votes to start with! Heh

@SpiderFighter: Good idea re: cross posting to another board where plates might not even know about the custom dungeons (some undoubtedly won't know about it!).

Is a mod considered a whole dungeon, or can it be a custom weapon, or some smaller piece?

I think anyone can make a poll - you just click to make a NEWTOPIC* and scroll down a little and there is a tab called "Poll creation" where you set all the options

and I think for this case we would be focusing on completed dungeons

pferguso wrote:Is a mod considered a whole dungeon, or can it be a custom weapon, or some smaller piece?

I think we should limit the voting to complete and tested dungeons.. to be a guide for the players who want some kind of review of mods.

For assets I think the endorsments on Nexus are a good pointer; plus they are used in strict categories: if I need a chair, the forest tileset - as cool and awesome as it is - is useless.

Komag wrote:I think anyone can make a poll - you just click to make a NEWTOPIC* and scroll down a little and there is a tab called "Poll creation" where you set all the options

and I think for this case we would be focusing on completed dungeons

• Options
  
  Disable BBCode
  Disable smilies
  Do not automatically parse URLs
  Attach a signature (signatures can be altered via the UCP)
  Notify me when a reply is posted

Negatory D:

JohnWordsworth wrote:Cool, seems like a positive response. Assuming the general consensus remains positive, I'll make December a draft run and then we can get an X-Mas mod of the month and start 2013 as we mean to go on!

Well the X-Mas mod of the month will clearly be the Frankendungeon, so...

Xanathar wrote:

X-Mas mod of the month

One Room ? (or is it non-competing ?)

Oh, wow...that WILL be a Christmas release, won't it??? I never thought about that. What a great month this is going to be for players!!

Definitely +1. If you are worried that one highlight per month is not enough, you may consider doing it bi-weekly or even weekly (or doing gold, silver, bronze thing). But keep in mind that this requires some amount of extra work, so be prepared for that.

One other thing we may consider is asking players to review the dungeons they played. Ideally, a review could be a couple of paragraphs long description of highlights and bigger issues, but many folks are not interested in writing essays.

For people with graphophobia we may invent a simple score system, like 1(pathetic)-10(superb) score in completeness, puzzles, monsters, fun, difficulty. Or perhaps that is something we could consider later when the whole thing starts rolling for good. Let's not overdo it from the beginning.

As for other points, I think we should allow only complete dungeons, not new items, props or monsters. This is end user oriented, not modders oriented contest.

I'm fine with letting older mods compete as long as they want to. In certain months there hopefully will be outburst of excellent dungeons. We should not penalize their authors, just because others have vacation at the same time.

thomson wrote:For people with graphophobia we may invent a simple score system, like 1(pathetic)-10(superb) score in completeness, puzzles, monsters, fun, difficulty.

I worry about forcing people to meta-review mods. If we do go with a "reward" for voters (as has been discussed earlier), we may unintentionally get some less-than-honest people who arbitrarily throw numbers up without actually playing through the mod/dungeon. Some of these puppies are huge, and I expect mine to take anywhere from 15-20 hours of solid playtime to finish (longer for treasure/secret hunters), and the Frungeon could be more massive than anything we've yet seen, depending on how many maps are submitted.

SpiderFighter wrote:I worry about forcing people to meta-review mods. If we do go with a "reward" for voters (as has been discussed earlier), we may unintentionally get some less-than-honest people who arbitrarily throw numbers up without actually playing through the mod/dungeon.

Ok, good point. We don't want to reinvent wheel here. Let's stick to simple voting + optional (appreciated, but not required) review then.